基于AGREEⅡ评价急性心力衰竭临床实践指南的质量.pdf

¼±ΣÖØ֢»¤Àí¹ÜÀíרÌâ Topical Issues »ùÓÚAGREE I IÆÀ¼Û¼±ÐÔÐÄÁ¦˥½ßÁÙ´² ʵ¼ùָÄϵÄÖÊÁ¿ ÕÅ·½Բ¿µÏþ·ïΤ±ûÆæÎ⺣ͮÀîá¿ [ժҪ¡¿ĿµÄ£º¶Ô¹úÄÚÍâ¼±ÐÔÐÄÁ¦˥½ßÁÙ´²ʵ¼ùָÄϽøÐÐÖÊÁ¿ÆÀ¼Û£¬ÒÔÆÚΪÁÙ´²ʵ¼ùÌṩ²Î¿¼¡£·½·¨£º¼ìË÷¹úÄÚ ÍâÎÄÏ×Êý¾Ý¿â¡¢ָÄÏÊý¾Ý¿â¼°Íøվ£¬°´ÕÕÄÉÈëºÍÅųý±ê׼ɸѡָÄÏ£»ʹÓÃAGREE 1IÆÀ¹À¹¤¾ß¶ÔָÄϽøÐÐÖÊÁ¿ÆÀ¼Û²¢ ͨ¹ý×éÄÚÏà¹ØϵÊý¶ÔÆÀ¼ÛÕß¼ä×ܵÄһÖÂÐÔ½øÐÐÆÀ¼Û¡£½á¹û£º¹²ÄÉÈë7ƪ¼±ÐÔÐÄÁ¦˥½ßÏà¹ØָÄÏ£¬ÆäÍƼö¼¶±ð¾ùΪB¼¶£¬ ÔÚAGREE¢ò6¸öÁìÓòµÄƽ¾ùµÃ·ÖÂÊ·Ö±ðΪ87£®10£¥¡¢63£®10£¥¡¢62£®50£¥¡¢87£®69£¥¡¢53£®13£¥ºÍ47£®32£¥¡£×éÄÚÏà¹ØϵÊýΪ0£®84 (P<0£®001)£¬ÆÀ¼ÛÕß¼ä×ܵÄһÖÂÐԷdz£ºÃ¡£½áÂÛ£ºÏÖÓм±ÐÔÐÄÁ¦˥½ßÁÙ´²ָÄÏ×ÜÌåÖÊÁ¿½Ï¸ß£¬µ«ÔÚÖƶ¨µÄ·½·¨ѧÉÏÈÔÓÐ ´ý½øһ²½µÄ¹æ·¶£¬ÓÈÆäÊÇӦÓÃÐԺͶÀÁ¢ÐÔÁìÓò¡£´ËÍ⣬¹úÍâָÄÏÔÚʹÓùý³ÌÖÐÐèҪ¿¼ÂÇÆäÊÇ·ñÊÊӦÎÒ¹úµÄÁÙ´²»·¾³¡£ ¡¾¹Ø¼ü´Ê¡¿ÐÄÁ¦˥½ß£»¼±ÐÔÐÄÁ¦˥½ß£»ָÄÏ£»ÆÀ¼Û£»AGREE 11 ¡¾ÖÐͼ·ÖÀàºÅ¡¿R47[DOI] 10£®3969£¯j£®issn£®1672¡ª1756£®2016£®01£®014 Quality appraisal of clinical practice guidelines for acute heart failure using AGREE II}ZHANG Fangyuan£® ¢ôGXiaofeng,WEIBingqi,WUHaitong,LIZheng£¯£¯School ofNursing£¬PekingUnionMedicalCollege£¬Beijing£¬100043 China£¯£¯£¯Chinese Nursing Management-2016£¬16f1)£º50-54 [Abstract]Objective£ºTo evaluate the qua1ity of clinical practice guidelines for acute heart failure in order to provide reference and consultation for clinical practice£®Methods£ºWe searched the databases of PubMed£®EMbase£®SinoMed£® CNKI£¬WanFang and the online resources such as SIGN£¬NICE£¬NGC RNA0 et a1£®to gather clinical practice guidelines nationally and internationally for acute heart failure£®¢ö£¬e reviewed and examined the chosen guidelines bv AGREE II instrument and meanwhile assessed the overall agreement among reviewers via the intragroup correlation coe±Òcient(icC¡¢£® Results£ºA total ofseven evidence¡ªbased guidelines for acute heart failure were finally included holding recommendation level B and the meal3 scores of six domains by AGRÍúI1 were 87£®10£¥£¬63£®10£¥£¬62£®50£¥£¬8 69£¥£¬53£®13£¥and 4 32£¥respectively£® Intragroup observer agreement was significantly good and t